September 14, 2009

Review: Doomsday Book, by Connie Willis



Some of you may have read Connie Willis's other time-travel novel, To Say Nothing of the Dog, and may subsequently have the impression that her books are just barrels of smart and witty laughs and giggles. Please allow me to correct this impression: Doomsday Book is smart and full of time-travelling Oxfordians, but humourous it is not. Beautiful, yes. Haunting, yes. Funny? Not so much.

I mean, come on. It's about the Black Plague.

Our story begins in Oxford in 2054 -- long after the great Pandemic that will soon strike us all, but not so long that it's been forgotten. Time travel exists, but isn't particularly glamourous; it's used primarily by historians wishing to do on-site research. Kivrin Engle is one such historian, and she has taught herself Latin masses and cow milking and Middle English in preparation for a two-week research stint in 1320. Her tutor, James Dunwoody, doesn't want her to go; the drop is being supervised by the incompetent Gilchrist, who hadn't even sent an unmanned probe to the 14th century before approving Kivrin's journey.

His worrying has no effect, however. Kivrin is sent back in time, and his own hands are soon full as a mysterious viral epidemic breaks out in Oxford. In the meantime, Kivrin has landed in the correct century, at more or less the correct place, and has been taken in by the family of Sir Guillaume D'Iverie: his wife, mother, and two young daughters.

Do I need to tell you that things go wrong? Things go very wrong -- wrong like there-goes-half-of-Europe wrong. The middle ages are brutal, but not as brutal as the plague that swept through them. [Aside: did you know that people still fall ill from bubonic plague? No joke. It's no picnic, I'm sure, but it's easily taken care of with antibiotics and such now. Still, can you imagine? "Uh, boss, I can't come in to work today ... yeah, I'm a bit sick ... bubonic plague, actually ... no, I'm serious, I have the plague ... hello? hello?" End of aside.]

A great strength of Doomsday Book is Willis's research, which must have been extensive and meticulous. The passages set in the middle ages are exquisitely realized. The filth and grit and vibrancy of the "contemps" are all there, and the picture that is painted of the way people actually lived is much more vivid and real than anything I've ever encountered in a history book, or even in much historical fiction. This works especially because the facts and facets of medieval life are inextricably grounded in the lives of the characters -- and history is about people, and stories, after all.

Of course, one of the great facets of medieval life was the Black Death, which swept through Europe first in the sixth century, and then in the fourteenth and for several centuries thereafter. It doesn't give away too much to tell you that plague happens in Doomsday Book, and that it's horrible. Have you ever really thought about what it's like when plague buboes burst? You will.

That being said, Doomsday Book is tragic but not entirely hopeless. The ending is bleak but strangely satisfying. You know, triumph of the human spirit, blah de blah de blah. It's pretty great.

9 comments:

MLO said...

Connie Willis is one of those authors who always delivers a good read. Each of her books has been unique and well worth the investment of time and money. Not to mention she is a very nice lady in person - or at least at conventions.

Fyrefly said...

That first paragraph absolutely applied to me when I read this. I went in expecting more hilarity and farce, like I'd gotten from TSNotD, which... what the heck was I thinking? The only time the Black Death is funny is Monty Python. :)
.-= Fyrefly´s last blog ..BBAW: Spreading the bloggy love =-.

Jo said...

Hi. This sounds good, mainly because I'm morbidly fascinated with Bubonic Plague!
.-= Jo´s last blog ..Mudbound by Hilary Jordan =-.

zibilee said...

I, too, have a big fascination with all things plague, and I loved this book when I read it a couple of years ago. I really loved Kivrin's gumption and thought she was a really interesting character. I wouldn't mind reading this one again. Great review, and I'm glad you liked the book.
.-= zibilee´s last blog ..The Man Who Loved Books Too Much by Allison Hoover Bartlett - 288 pages =-.

Christine said...

Fyrefly -- I also read TSNotD first, but I was prewarned that this book was going to be sad, so it didn't catch me by surprise. (Would purists say that the warning ruined some of the books' poignancy? I dunno.)

And a note for those considering this book -- you might want to read To Say Nothing of the Dog before you read this one. I was reading reviews of Doomsday on LibraryThing, and one common point made was the Willis really glosses over the time travel, and that little explanation is given for how it works, etc. I think that this is partially explained by the fact that it's not really necessary to the story except as a device that gets her to the middle ages; but, further to that, Willis does go into much more detail in her earlier work. To Say Nothing of the Dog is full of paradoxes and drops and how time-travel works, and why it's been relegated to scholars and bureauocrats -- and so if you're the type who needs to understand that before you can willfully suspend your disbelief, please read it first. And for the rest of you, you can read it as well, because it is excellent.

raych said...

I loved the hell out of this book. Also, after I finished I just sat and felt sad for, like, half an hour. SO BLEAK! But so satisfying.
.-= raych´s last blog ..Eating Well, Living Well: An Everyday Guide for Optimum Health - Richard BĂ©liveau, PhD and Denis Gringras, PhD =-.

Dave Robus said...

As someone who lives in a town about one mile from among the very first of the villages to be mentioned in the original "domesday book" I am intrigued. It looks like I will be adding Connie Willis Doomsday book to my collection especially as I am interested in everything old.

DaveRobus.

Adam Teece said...

I loved your novel, I also have read books that are nonfiction and it can help us people to motivate our lifestyle, specially to the businessman there are lots of advice and articles that might be useful in motivating your business. These site also help us face when we feel that our life have moved to the next level. there are helpful articles and guides. For more details please visit Thesuccessfulgeek.com. Thank you
.-= Adam Teece´s last blog ..1/18/10 =-.

Doomsday Book by Connie Willis | A Good Stopping Point said...

[...] She Reads Books – “Doomsday Book is tragic but not entirely hopeless. The ending is bleak but strangely satisfying.” [...]